A discussion that keeps popping up, what is the legality of genetic powers from the genetics lab and to what degree should we see people using them? On one extreme we have everyone and the assistant’s grandmother fully upgraded with X-ray, TK gene, and Thermal resistance. Able to see through every wall and make objects float around or even open doors from the hidden safety of just behind an iron wall.
Able to spy from across the screen with no way to hide from it, and throw lockers and toolboxes and even swords to kill someone from a safe distance. And then on the other hand we have no one ever using genetics powers for any reason, and the moment someone does walk out with a glowing head or an eerie shimmer in their eyes both the individual and the geneticist are arrested for contraband.
Normally we aren’t anywhere near these two extremes of imbalance, either overwhelmingly powerful or completely useless, NORMALLY we don’t have a geneticist at all because there just isn’t a point to them, and no one has any genemodded powers in-game. Every now and then someone new will play geneticist, learn all of the different powers, and then hand them out either like candy to any squeak who asks, or to a handful of people they trust, or sometimes just outright soliciting powers to people who could benefit from them most.
Hulk to each of the heads, X-ray for security, thermals for anyone who does spacewalking like the minors. But then they get shouted at. Being helpful gets them in trouble (or being dangerous gets them in trouble as they take it too far) and then they stop playing geneticist, and then no one see’s any genemods for another month or so until some new person shows up wanting to see all the toys and be helpful. Just for this process to start all over again.
I’m aware from some admins that this is already on the agenda, notably Nightwing had a few ideas for how to go about changing things, but now its time for an actual discussion thread to get more ideas and more people talking in here. The problem is that we want genetics to be useful. We don’t want security, HoS, captain and HoP, or the general crew all being a dick to the geneticist player. We don’t want a CMO telling the geneticist to delete every bit of data they found and remove all their luck earned work, as I’ve seen happen before.
We don’t want security rushing in to tell a geneticist that they aren’t allowed to do their job, and should never mess with or hand out any of the toys that are expressly their entire purpose to the station. Yes there is also cloning, but the rest of the medical staff, including the therapist, should all know how to press the clone button and toss someone into a cryo tube without spilling blood across the floor. The geneticist should handle genetics, and if they aren’t allowed to do so they might as well be a nurse.
____________
But the counter-argument I keep seeing, thermals is EVA access, don’t go handing it to assistants … except its not. It should be, but it only really prevents burn damage, which means under normal conditions its only viable purpose is to prolong digestion. It might be usable in fighting fires, one would logically think, but we so rarely have genetic powers at all and so rarely get fires, that I’ve never seen this tested. I hope it works. It should work. It would be awesome for fire fighting.
TK meanwhile is a downright weapon, able to pick people off from a distance and steal over countertops, even kill people without leaving a trace of evidence.
X-ray is an invasion of privacy and would be far too effective in finding run-aways and stamping out crime, which is a legitimate concern.
And worse TK and X-ray together makes you an ultimate stealth assassin who can beat people to death from the other side of a wall, all without leaving any evidence and never revealing yourself.
Hulk speaks for itself, and other than the idea that you should blindly murder a hulked person even if they are calmly coming in to security or medbay asking to be unhulked, it is NOTHING BUT a weapon and should be treated as a deadly weapon, seeing as its such amazing protection with the stun immunity and it can break through just about any form of confinement. I personally want to test spider webs and gift-wrapping because I suspect a hulk can’t break out of those, but that would require a test subject. And spiders. Which we don’t normally have since Chang’s mysterious disappearance.
Thermal resistance is the only power that can’t be actively harmful, and even then I don’t think its intentional, if thermal resistance offered full EVA capabilities while naked and wearing a gas mask and air tank then it still might offer dangerous possibilities.
_____________
From what I can see, all of the ways to abuse genetic powers are exactly the same ways you can abuse any other tool. Beyond hulk, you can use gloves to avoid fingerprints, you can put on a gas mask to not reveal yourself, you can beat people to death with a toolbox found at arrivals or inject them with sneakier things by just filling a cup with some hard liquor and force-feeding it to them. Something I’ve seen a botanist do, effortlessly down a security officer who wielded a butcher’s knife by just throwing cups at his apparently open mouth until he fell asleep. Its not like the capacity to be a dick will suddenly go away just because the extra powers from genetics aren’t available, or are too heavily restricted.
Aaaaat the same time you really don’t want to encourage people to be a dick by making it too easy, or making it the logical option. See Hulk again, no one needs 50 brute damage with an unarmed attack unless they are going on an away mission and want a diverse team of specialists. Its not like the people who don’t want genetic powers being easy to access are talking out of their ass, this is a valid point and relates to just how overpowered each of these four incredible super-powers are.
Those playing geneticist, do you really want to spend somewhere between 30 minutes to 6 hours pressing a button over and over again and hoping that the random number generator will be in your favor, only to achieve something that no one will ever use, no one will ever benefit from, and if you use it yourself or give it to your friends you can be arrested for contraband and then fired from your work? Standard bay had a solution to the problem of genetics being either too overpowered or not used at all. They just removed genetics. Entirely. Leaving an empty, destroyed room in it’s place as a message to the other jobs out there.
I really don’t want this to be the solution we go with, and seeing how many people have messing with genetics in their backstory removing it would be a major change to the entire lore. Make it harder to justify players who want to sign in as a different race, or a different sex. Would be a bit less diversity and imagination, even if just a tiny bit.
___________
Solutions:
Genetics needs to be USEFUL somehow, and preferably useful to every player or some other department. It needs to be codified and clear, we don’t want the CMO giving one set of orders and the RD giving another. And we don’t want every single option being a game ending super-power that can turn an assistant into a godlike assassin. Last of all, we want more diversity than just 4 things that help people and 15 things that involve being a dick to whoever you inject.
1: Remove genetics from medical entirely, put it in research instead.
Make genetics research a pure science station with it’s own surgery table and chemistry sets to apply medical treatment to any unmonkeys. Just enough to cure broken bones or genetic damage, no cryo tubes and no way to replace medical proper. Think of the equivalent of robotics having it’s own surgery table for the removal of brains and xenoarch having its own chemistry machine for gathering acid. Set genetic research under the sole direction of the research director and leave medical out of it entirely. Unlike other stations our medical have to be able to clone people at any time, as it’s the most common form of injury, and we have no reason to tell nurses and therapists that clones don’t exist. Remove ‘cloning patients’ from a genetisist’s job list, make their job only to gather the genetic powers for research and testing. Stop with the confusion of who has what control with split directions from CMO and RD. Potentially give CMO genetics access into science? Not sure. Just make sure medical also has the capability to repair genetic damage.
2: More diverse genetic powers:
Make more powers, and make the powers significantly weaker. Powers of convenience rather than powers of domination. Make hunger tick down at a slower rate, mild increases and decreases to temperature tolerance on par with what standard races come equipt with, that stacks with existing temperature tolerance. Not outright immune to temperature, but less vulnerable or more resistant. Better nightvision. Total nightvision. Claws, teeth, or fists on a species that does not normally have those, changing their unarmed damage type and changing their hand type, to get a human with claws who can’t wear gloves, or an tajaran with a shark jaw who chomps instead of slashes. Able to move at speeds as if they were wearing shoes, despite being barefoot. Skin pouches, so they can still have pockets to put things in even when naked, count as if wearing clothing despite having nothing in the clothing or jacket slot. Telescopic vision, able to see across the map a few extra tiles as if wielding a sniper rifle. Small things, interesting things, stuff that makes your life easier but doesn’t give you complete and total domination in some area of expertise with no real counter. Come up with some on your own please, this thread is the perfect place for it.
3: Remove the Random Number Generator element.
No matter what is done to balance the genetic powers and the station hierarchy, that won’t change the fact genetics is downright punishing to play, and for no good reason. It’s an excursive in frustration specifically designed to go against roleplay, preventing you from meeting people unless you have some outside reason to call them into your office, and preventing you from chatting with them because you’d have to take your hands off the console to talk. These are not good features for a roleplay server. Even two geneticists working together are just silently going about the motions as each one cuts the workload of the other in half. Theoretically. The RNG is designed to screw with people who think they found the right block, as there are several layers of random numbers in play here. So! Instead of forcing the geneticist to sit quietly and press a button over and over, take advantage of the fact this station’s lore involves a diverse and unusual cast of crewmembers in which even those seemingly human have unusual capabilities and mixed DNA.
Have the way you gather genetic powers involve gathering other players and scanning in their genetic data, then pressing a button to process that data and get either powers or disabilities out of it. Either automatically if you want to be nice, or part of some mini-game if you want to be cruel. The more options the better. Make unique unmonkeys a viable source for genetic information, make each person’s scan data work only once, and encourage testing on assistants and others while making it a thing that only takes a few minutes of someone’s time. If you have a small crew you get less work done and the work is a bit harder making the unmonkeys. If you have a large crew then the more people donating their data the better the research goes along. Maybe coordinate with medical to allow scan data from their scanners to count toward the DNA genetics has access to if they link the servers, and vice-versa with genetic’s scan data acting as a backup in case medbay scan data is compromised. Get people talking to each other, get the geneticist to be someone who scours the halls asking for subjects to scan in. Make it something engaging to play, as opposed to sitting quietly and waiting for the job to be over.
_______________
If anyone has any counter-point or their own ideas, even better if anyone has something for a minor super-power or a power that’s worth adding to the eventual list, please speak up now.